Forecasting the Oscars ® since 2003

"It's not about who we want to win,

It's about who will"

HOME
Agenda
Chart
Forums
Precursors
Reviews
Specials
BLOG TALK
PREDICTIONS 2007

FILM REVIEWS (2007 RELEASES)

Picture
Director
Actor
 

"NO COUNTRY FOR OLD MEN" (R)

Javier Bardem is deserving of an Oscar in "No Country for Old Men"

By Josh Kirschenbaum

The opening scene of No Country for Old Men, an exquisitely crafted thriller from Ethan and Joel Coen, features a voiceover monologue from Sheriff Ed Tom Bell (Tommy Lee Jones, in the best role of his career). Jones recites his lines in a Texas drawl that is nearly indecipherable. I advise you to listen closely for what he says: his character is the moral center of the film. On seemingly opposite ends of the moral spectrum are Llewellyn Moss (Josh Brolin) and Anton Chigurh (Javier Bardem).

While hunting, Moss comes across what looks like a drug deal gone sour. He finds a satchel of money and runs off with it, thereby setting the stage for one of the most thrilling pursuits in the history of film as Chigurh (who’s connection to the money is never fully explained) sets off after him.

Brolin plays his role subtly, never letting on more than necessary. The Coens pace their film with similar resolve, preferring to let on just enough to keep you intrigued, but hardly informed. The Coens have always been master filmmakers; they have a penchant for choosing the exact right shot at the exact right moment. In recent years, however, they have let their trademarks overwhelm them, resulting in substance-less films like Intolerable Cruelty and The Ladykillers. In No Country for Old Men, they seemingly let go of everything that makes them unique, but only seemingly. In reality, they have simply made their trademarks less apparent. The razor sharp dialogue is still there, as is their signature dark humor. But while most Coen films have a playful quality to them (even Fargo, in all its bloody glory, was terrifically fun to watch), No Country is pitch black. It is a gritty, visceral picture.

The film’s violent nature comes in no small part from the actions of Anton Chigurh. This brings me to the incomparable Javier Bardem. With Chigurh, Bardem has created the most brilliantly complex villain I’ve ever seen. To compare him to Daniel Day-Lewis in Gangs of New York would be unfair. Day-Lewis’s performance, while absolutely magnificent, does not have the depth of Bardem’s. It doesn’t really matter how high you’re expectations are, you will be blown over nonetheless. Not only will he be nominated for the Oscar®, but if there’s any justice in the world, he’ll win it. But there is more to this film than just him.

Woody Harrelson and Stephen Root (the only Coen regular in the cast) do well with what little roles they have. As does Kelly Macdonald, playing the wife of Brolin’s Llewellyn Moss. But while no one comes close to Bardem, Jones is the only one who manages to not be overshadowed. He plays a role startlingly different to his roles of the past, mostly because all of his past roles have been little more than caricatures of the same persona. Here he plays a fully formed human being, and plays him well.

Sheriff Bell investigates the leftovers of Moss and Chigurh’s cat-and-mouse game (a dead body here, a burnt car there) with an unintelligent deputy played by Garret Dillahunt. You’re probably thinking this sounds familiar to Fargo, where Frances McDormand worked with similarly dim fellow police officers. Yet Marge Gunderson and Ed Tom Bell are completely different characters. Gunderson kept her positive demeanor despite the violent happenings around her. Bell is supremely affected by what he sees, and Jones’ performance lets us know it. While he has little chance to be nominated in the supporting category, the praise from this film could spillover into buzz for his leading role in In the Valley of Elah (which received favorable reviews).

The scenes between Moss and Chigurh are brilliantly constructed. The Coens, being the masters they are, create scenes of unimaginable tension. Yet they never forget that at its center, No Country for Old Men is about people, not events. The film takes a surprising turn in the third act. Instead of finishing the film with an epic shootout (as is the custom in westerns and thrillers), the Coens take the time to create a fully realized denouement. The result is an absolutely haunting film of remarkable depth. Many people have called No Country for Old Men a return to form, but it’s more than that: It’s a clear sign that the Coens are growing in their filmmaking, and the result is marvelous.

****/****

 
Actress
Supporting Actor
Supp. Actress
Screenplays
Artistic / Techs
Golden Globes

FEATURES

Archive
Chart
Precursors

COMMUNITY

About Us
Bait an Oscar
Forums
Links

REVIEWS

Index