Forecasting the Oscars ® since 2003

"It's not about who we want to win,

It's about who will"

HOME
Agenda
Chart
Forums
Precursors
Reviews
Specials
BLOG TALK
PREDICTIONS 2007

FILM REVIEWS (2007 RELEASES)

Picture
Director
Actor
 

"THE KITE RUNNER" (PG-13)

Marc Forster's emotional drama The Kite Runner brings something special to this year's Oscar race

By Johnny Alba

In a year were most of the films touted as Oscar contenders (even those competing for the Comedy/Musical spot on the Best Picture race) are too dark, too violent or both; Paramount Vantage’s spellbinding awards-hopeful The Kite Runner offers the kind of poignant storytelling and social relevance that AMPAS has effortlessly embraced in recent years.

Based on the vastly popular novel by Khaled Hosseini, the Afghanistan-centered drama (partially spoken on the Dari dialect) chronicles the return of LA-based writer Amir (Khalid Abdalla) to his homeland after a long, painful exile. Staying faithful to the beloved source material, the film focuses on the childhood friendship of privileged Amir and his kite-flying friend (also the son of his father Baba’s servant) Hassan; the tragic events that destroyed their bond and Amir’s last chance to make up to his former friend for his past mistakes.

The film, just like the novel, is all about contrasts: the glow of the 70’s Kabul where Amir and Hassan would spend their days flying kites is gone on the 2000's grim zone of conflict, Amir’s father Baba is no longer an influential personality in America and most importantly; the boys’ innocence contrasts with the hate, the discrimination and the evil they can’t even imagine will haunt them for the rest of their lives.

Just like Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu in Babel, director Marc Forster makes great use of his international, mostly unknown, cast to develop believable, flawed individuals. During the vibrant (and longest) segment of Amir and Hassan’s childhood; young actors Zekeria Ebrahimi and Ahmad Khan Mahmidzada carry the film with infecting candor and joy. During the surprisingly-good CGI-generated kite flying sequences, the boys’ dreams come true and we, as viewers, can fully relate to their feelings and remember we once were just like them. When the boys must meet with the harsh, real world; both children show a very mature understanding of the events around them and their consequences.

Khalid Adballa is also convincing and remarkably expressive as the tortured Amir (a role that will probably open many doors in Hollywood for the Scottish actor) but it is Homayon Ershadi as Baba who truly shines from the adult cast (which also includes Shaun Toub and Atossa Leoni in solid supporting turns). On his Afghan life, Ershadi conveys the intensity necessary to make Baba a very divisive personality but the actor is also able to show the frustrations and nostalgia of an immigrant now reduced to pump gas in California.

Marc Forster’s subtle direction is highly effective (the much-discussed rape scene is cleverly shot) and his sophisticated comprehension of ideal film narrative allows the story to stay away from the novel’s melodrama. The emotional screenplay by David Benioff is both convincing and confident; the writer realized what parts of the novel needed to be sacrificed in order to develop Amir and Hassan’s relationship and his director understood that an acclaimed novel can still be successfully innovated and improved.

Ultimately, the risky artistic and creative freedom taken by Forster and his team pay off and the result is one of the most touching and intuitive dramas in recent years; one that book fans will still enjoy and one that AMPAS members are more than likely to empathize with...

***1/2/****

 
Actress
Supporting Actor
Supp. Actress
Screenplays
Artistic / Techs
Golden Globes

FEATURES

Archive
Chart
Precursors

COMMUNITY

About Us
Bait an Oscar
Blog
Forums
Links

REVIEWS

Index