Forecasting the Oscars ® since 2003

"It's not about who we want to win,

It's about who will"

HOME
Agenda
Chart
Forums
Precursors
Reviews
Specials
BLOG TALK
PREDICTIONS 2007

FILM REVIEWS (2007 RELEASES)

Picture
Director
Actor
 

"EASTERN PROMISES" (R)

Naomi Watts and Viggo Mortensen star in Cronenberg's riveting "Eastern Promises"

By Clayton Davis

Eastern Promises, the highly anticipated film by A History of Violence director David Cronenberg is an exceedingly riveting motion picture. It is jam-packed with elevated levels of suspense, top notch performances and a storyline to die for.

The film tells the story of Nikolai and Anna; two people who's paths cross and unravels a very powerful mystery at hand. When Anna (played exquisitely by Naomi Watts) finds a young infant it leads her to London's most powerful families which could ultimately destroy her and her family. In the middle of the dilemma is Nikolai, (in Viggo Mortensen's best performance to date) whose presence brings shutter to the viewer.

While Mortensen and Watts turn in flawless performances Oscar may have problems with both. With Mortensen, we run into the same problem we did with A History of Violence, a seamless execution of artistry but too reserved for Oscar's forte. Naomi Watts may fall into the Maria Bello problem of category confusion. This critic is unsure of where to place her, but she may fair
better in supporting but alas, the performance itself doesn't measure to her 21 Grams work.

The revelation of the picture comes from the Oscar nominated Armin Mueller-Stahl who brings fear and torment to the audience as "Semyon," the head of the London crime family. His "Semyon" (who is reminiscent of Jack Nicholson's snubbed work in The Departed) brings sheer brilliance to his role and may be an unseen frontrunner in the upcoming Oscar race. As Alan Arkin captured his Oscar last year for veteran status, Stahl may do the same.

Vincent Cassel also turns in an accomplished performance but with his character having such an unlikable factor and no true "Oscar scene" to stand on, Cassel may be overshadowed greatly by Stahl. Cassel plays "Kirill," the son of Semyon and heir to the throne of the crime family. His spoiled "Kirill" is as obnoxious as he is compassionate and cowardly as he is sensitive. Cassel is an actor to watch in the near future.

But with uncharted work coming from the actors and a smooth elegant script by Oscar nominated Steven Knight, the praise and commendation merits to the overdue director, David Cronenberg. This is a very Cronenberg-like film with huge amounts of violence and much talked about naked Viggo fight sequence but with the capture of the tone, aggression and subject matter of the motion picture, Cronenberg excels once again in a genre he's all too familiar with. He'll probably be a personal favorite this year for a nomination but Oscar tends to not favor this type of work.

Eastern Promises, is a crime thriller of the ages but doesn't rank with previous works like The Departed and Goodfellas but should categorized on its own. An outstanding work with excellent cinematography and an even potent score; this film is quite enjoyable and keeps its promises indeed.

****/****

 
Actress
Supporting Actor
Supp. Actress
Screenplays
Artistic / Techs
Golden Globes

FEATURES

Archive
Chart
Precursors

COMMUNITY

About Us
Bait an Oscar
Forums
Links

REVIEWS

Index