Forecasting the Oscars ® since 2003

"It's not about who we want to win,

It's about who will"

HOME
Calendar
Chart
Forums
Precursors
Reviews
Specials
BLOG TALK
PREDICTIONS 2007

FILM REVIEWS (2007 RELEASES)

Picture
Director
Actor
Actress
 

"BORDERTOWN" (R)

Directed by Gregory Nava

Starring Jennifer Lopez, Martin Sheen, Sonia Braga & Antonio Banderas

Jennifer Lopez stars in Bordertown, one of the worst films of the year

By Johnny Alba

Lauren Adrien (Jennifer Lopez), a cutthroat journalist from The Chicago Sentinel, is sent against her wishes to cover the notorious murders of hundreds of female workers in the stereotypical bordertown of Juarez, Mexico. Soon after her arrival though, she discovers there is more about the murders than the government wants the world to know and she also finds herself more involved than she would have thought. It’s on this premise where all the problems begin for this ludicrous film as writer and director Gregory Nava provides a very superficial approach to the real-life events and instead, invests most of his energies on sending a manipulative anti-globalization and anti-NAFTA (North American Free Trade Agreement) speech. The film debuted to boos at the past Berlinale and I thought most of this story was exaggerated by the international press but if anyone cares to watch it like I did, they will undoubtedly get the boos from the moment the opening credits start rolling.

As the film’s heroine, Adrien is poorly developed and is never believable as a “blonde american” trying to solve the massive murders that according to the film, both the mexican and american government are hiding for economic reasons. Jennifer Lopez does nothing to lift her character above the pages and therefore, make us care little for her actions and motivations.

Antonio Banderas is more natural as Alfonso Diaz, Adrien’s former co-worker/love interest, who is trying to solve the murders himself as the editor of the only newspaper willing to say the truth in Juarez. Martin Sheen and brazilian actress Sonia Braga do their best in minor and underwritten roles.

Directed with major clumsiness by Gregory Nava and appropriately scripted as a bland TV-movie, “Bordertown” has an atmospheric thriller vibe, a very bad one that is. Oscar-wise, this film is obviously out of all races and it probably never was despite early pre-production buzz.

0/****

 
Supporting Actor
Supp. Actress
Screenplays
Artistic / Techs
Golden Globes

FEATURES

Archive
Awards Agenda
Chart
Interview
Precursors
Top 10 Opinions

COMMUNITY

About Us
Bait an Oscar
Blog
Forums

REVIEWS

Index